How to Prevent Identity Theft after the New Federal Law Changes

Effective September 22, 2018, a new federal law requires credit bureaus to allow consumers to freeze their credit for free. 

On May 24, 2018, President Trump signed the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief and Consumer Protection Act, which requires the three major credit bureaus: Experian, TransUnion and Equifax, to allow consumers to freeze their credit at no cost.    

 A credit freeze prevents other people or institutions from pulling credit information on an individual.  Effectively it keeps identity thieves from opening a new account or loan in a person’s name.

This new law passed by Congress came after Equifax had a major data breach in 2017 that exposed personal information of 143 million Americans.  Hackers were able to steal sensitive information which included addresses, dates of birth, Social Security, driver’s license and credit card numbers.

How a Credit Freeze Works

The process requires contacting all three credit bureaus, Experian, Trans Union and Equifax, to request a credit freeze.  The credit bureaus will then provide a PIN which should be kept in a safe and secure location.

If credit is needed to process a loan, the individual or couple will then have to unfreeze their accounts by contacting the three credit bureaus and providing the assigned PIN either over phone or online.  Keep in mind that it can take up to 3 business days to unfreeze credit.

In the past, it could have cost a couple up to $216 to freeze credit, unfreeze it to get a loan, and then refreeze their credit again.  Now that this is free, it makes a credit freeze a more reasonable strategy to help prevent identity theft. 

Should you do a Credit Freeze?

Freezing your credit can be time consuming, but it keeps others from opening new accounts in your name.  However, if you check your credit annually and you intend to borrow from new lenders, it might not be worth the hassle. 

If you want to ensure that one significant avenue of ID theft is protected, it can be a great idea.

While a credit freeze does keep others from opening new accounts in your name, it does not solve all ID theft issues. 

Changes to Fraud Alert

The new law also extends a fraud alert on a credit report from 90 days to one year.  A fraud alert requires lenders to verify the identity of the individual before issuing credit.  Unlike the credit freeze, a single request to one credit bureau is all that is needed.  The one credit bureau is required to communicate the fraud alert with the other two.

A fraud alert does not freeze the credit, but it makes it much more difficult for a thief to open a fictitious account.

Freezing credit or relying on fraud alerts are two possible steps in protecting your ID against potential financial loss. 

Additional Ways to Protect Yourself from Identity Theft

1.   Use strong passwords

-     Use different passwords for each account

-     Create unique passwords, no family names

-     Change passwords frequently

-     Consider a password manager

2.   Set up two-factor authentication

-     This requires an account to take a second action to verify account holder making it much more difficult for a thief to get into one of your accounts

-     Turn this on for all financial accounts: bank accounts, credit cards. etc.

3.   Keep all devices secure

-     Use screen locks, pins and passwords for all computers, tablets and phones

-     Enable encryption for stored data

-     Avoid public Wi-Fi for any account transactions or purchases unless you have a separate VPN (Virtual Private Network)

-     Always use security software with firewall, anti-virus and anti-malware

-     Keep your smart phone secure, it is often where your second-factor codes are sent

4.   Sign up for alerts on accounts

-     Most online accounts will send alerts to your phone or through email when used

-     This is especially important for credit cards and bank cards that are subject to skimming - where thieves steal your card information and sell it or use it

5.   Keep personal information secure

-     Shred receipts, credit applications, medical records, anything that has your personal information

-     Limit the use of your Social Security number

-     Keep your financial documents safe at home, at work and in public

6.   Be alert to imposters

-     Don’t give out personal information on the phone, over the internet or by mail unless you know the company and the purpose for the information

-     Don’t respond to emails asking for personal information.  If a company requests your information on line, do not respond to the email but go directly to the companies’ site or call the customer service number on your statement

7.   Whether you freeze your credit or not, check your credit report

-     Get a free credit report annually

-     Consider using a credit monitoring service that alerts you to new accounts

8.  Remember to consider all family members

-     Don’t forget your children.  Be alert.  If your child gets a tax notice, a bill collection call or a credit card application it might be a sign someone is using their ID.  Get a credit report before they turn 16.  It should be blank, but you have time to get it cleared up before they need credit if something is in error

-     Be careful of elderly family members that might not know how to prevent ID theft.  If it does happen to them, they often feel ashamed and do nothing about it.  Since the elderly are prime targets, having a plan for them is essential.  A best practice is having multiple family members monitor their financial records on a regular routine

Identity theft happens to millions of people every year.  Taking these measures does not guarantee your ID will not be stolen but it does put you and your family in a place to minimize the chance of it happening.  If an issue does come up, you will be more likely to identify it and be able to respond quickly.


Human Investing
3 Steps To Automate Your Way To Financial Wellness
 

There is something intriguing about having a domesticated robot like C-3PO (Star Wars), Number 5 (Short Circuit), or Wall-E (Wall-E) to help with everyday tasks that while important are hard to find time to complete. Today our cell phones notify us with the time it will take to get home, refrigerators send us shopping lists (that is if no one is shopping for you) vacuums clean our homes, cars park themselves and it seems as though one day they will all drive themselves. In this day of helpful technology here are three simple tools to automate your finance.

Auto Increase: Auto Increase can help you reach your retirement savings goals without breaking the bank. It’s essential for most people to save at least 15% of their gross income for retirement, however, this can be difficult. If saving 15% is inconceivable, start small and use automation to help. Some retirement plans allow you to set up an annual increase of your contribution percentage. Increasing your savings rate by just 1 percent each year can have a powerful impact on your retirement balance.

Example: A 35yr old with an annual income of $50k begins saving 5% into her 401k by age 65 she can expect to have a balance of $335k. Now if she were to set up an annual auto increase of 1% she could increase her retirement balance to over $825k.

A 1% auto increase can add almost $490k to your retirement balance!!!

Source: dinkytown.net

Source: dinkytown.net

Hint: Set up your auto-escalation to coincide with the time period you typically get a pay increase. This strategy will help decrease the impact on your bank account.

Auto Rebalance: Setting up auto rebalance can help you avoid unnecessary risk in changing markets. With stocks up 13.57% and bonds up 2.59% annualized over the last 5 years (see graph), you could be taking on some additional risk with an out of balance retirement account. Automating your account or taking the time once a year to rebalance your portfolio can help disperse some of this risk.

Example: Say five years ago an individual had $20,000 in their retirement plan and purposely invested 50% of their portfolio in stocks and the other 50% in bonds, a 50/50 ratio. Over the last 5 years, this account would have grown by 51% to over $30k. In the short period, the purposeful 50/50 portfolio would now be a 62/38 ratio of stock to bonds. This change in the stock/bond ratio can alter the individual’s portfolio and add additional risk.

The graph below highlights the growth of $10,000 invested in the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Admiral (VTSAX) compared to the growth of the Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund Admiral (VBTLX) from August 2013 until August 2018. $10,000 invested in stocks (VTSAX) would have grown to almost $19,000 while $10,000 in a bond fund (VBTLX) would have grown to just over $11,000.

Source: Morningstar.com

Source: Morningstar.com

Automate your Emergency Reserve: American’s now have more credit-card debt than ever, passing the $1 Trillion mark, paying an average of 17.03% interest. To help avoid being stifled by such expensive debt it is important to build an emergency reserve. Building an emergency reserve of at least 6 months of your income can help keep you on track when unexpected expenses come up. Banks’ digital presence makes it easier than ever to automate saving. Rather than waiting to the end of each month to see what’s left over, if you know you get paid on the 1st of the month set up an automatic transfer to your emergency reserve on the 2nd day of the month. Setting up the automatic transfer helps force yourself to be more strategic with your dollars.

Conclusion: Whether you are wary of robots taking over or are excited to pawn off the mundane (like these robots that open doors), taking a few minutes to set yourself up for success can point you and your family in the direction of financial wellness.  

And while Artificial Intelligence can help with much, it can never replace the value of a face-to-face interaction. At Human Investing, our team of world-class humans aim to serve your pursuit of a fuller life with tailored financial planning and advice. This goes beyond the “nuts and bolts” of investing and financial planning and into the heart of why we do what we do.

 

 
 

Related Articles

Is Your Mission in Jeopardy?
 

(Reprinted from the Nonprofit Association of Oregon)

How you can build and fortify your donor base

With the recent Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 – which became effective January 1, 2018 – there’s concern that the increase in standard deduction will dis-incentivize donors who will no longer receive a tax deduction for their charitable giving. This could pose a challenge to nonprofits who rely on consistent donor funding – and it’s not to be discounted. However, while it’s true that a charitable tax deduction is an incentive, it’s not the only reason people give. Northwesterners in particular love their nonprofits. They care deeply about communities, they care about causes and they give in increasing numbers. We’re encouraging nonprofits to plan, be proactive and make sure donors know the impact of their investments. Importantly, this could be an opportune time to modify your fundraising perspective and consider new ways to energize your donor base.

Qualified Charitable Distributions from an Individual Retirement Account

One consideration is to inform your donors who are 70.5 years or older that they are eligible to make charitable contributions from their tax deferred Individual Retirement Accounts. Retirement account holders may distribute up to $100,000 per year, including their Required Minimum Distribution, directly to a nonprofit and avoid taxes on the distribution. These distributions avoid ordinary income tax but also reduce the potential income tax liability on Social Security and may lower Medicare premiums.

Donor Advised Funds

Another opportunity exists for nonprofits to further understand Donor Advised Funds and inform their donor base about the benefits. A DAF is a vehicle where a donor can make a charitable contribution, immediately receive eligible tax deductions and then distribute donations to one or multiple nonprofits of their choice in any time frame. The contributions can be invested and any potential growth is tax-free. Additionally, donors may contribute both cash and non-cash gifts to a DAF.

With the standard deduction now doubled, donors may find that itemizing doesn’t make sense in 2018 and beyond. One tax-planning strategy called “bunching” can help donors maintain their charitable deductions. They may contribute multiple years of charitable giving in one year to surpass the itemization threshold, and in off-years take the standard deduction. Please see the example below. A DAF can operate as a central location to receive, invest and distribute the contributions.

 
 
tax strategy.jpg
 
 

Accept Non-Cash Gifts

Finally, nonprofits should consider providing a method for non-cash donations such as stocks, real estate or other assets. This can be particularly advantageous when the donation is an appreciated asset that has been owned for one-year or longer. In this case, the donor is able to receive a tax deduction for the entire value of the asset while avoiding long-term capital gains from the sale of the asset.

If these types of donations cannot be supported by the nonprofit, a DAF will likely handle the transition and sale of the asset and then the contributions to the donor’s nonprofit of choice.

This is an opportune time to seek out donors who may be looking for creative tax-planning strategies. While this information may be helpful, please consult your CPA for specifics about how these tax strategies will affect your nonprofit organization and donor base.

Human Investing is a certified B-Corporation, a member of NAO and an Oregon-based financial firm serving the financial pursuits of both nonprofit organizations and individual donors. If you would like to learn more, we’d love to hear from you.

 
Human Investing
How to Avoid the Negative Compounding Effect of Fees on Your Account
 
leaky-bucket-fees.jpg

Despite the recent awareness around fees in today's environment, it can still be challenging for investors to know what and whom they are paying.

I was reminded of this recently when we had the pleasure of welcoming a family in as new clients to our firm. When they first reached out to us, they knew something was not right with their investment situation. After reviewing their statements and a discovery call, we quickly found out why. They were being overcharged and underserved. It turns out their fees were roughly 2.12% per year. At the same time, the level of service they were receiving included one phone call per year, online access and statements.

In this article, my goal is to unwrap the fee structure that this family experienced, highlight the long-term negative impact and then provide an awareness that can help you avoid this situation.

Moreover, while this article focuses on the experience of a single family, we have seen the same cost structure apply directly to institutions as well, whether an endowment, foundation, ERISA retirement plan or other types of institutional assets.

The step-by-step on how to give up 25% of your market returns to your advisor (not recommended!)

The family mentioned above did not realize they were charged fees on fees. One layer included an advisor fee of 1.40% per year with limited services. Unfortunately, industry expertise, full client engagement, risk management, along with estate and financial planning were not part of the offering. 

The second layer of fees was the underlying costs of the investments held in the portfolio—which was new information to the clients. Even though they had a diversified mix of “institutional” mutual funds in their account, the average expense ratio of these investments was 0.72%, which was added to the 1.40%.

 Without digging deeper into other potential underlying fees such as trading costs and custodial fees, the total costs were 2.12% per year. (1.4% + 0.72% = 2.12%)

Assuming a 9% long-term average return(1) in the stock market, these clients had been giving up almost 25% of return per year in fees. Unless there is some other form of benefit or return the client is receiving, this is retirement money down the drain. In Peter Fisher’s 2018 article in Forbes titled, “Why Conflicting Retirement Advice is Crushing American Households,"(2) he points out that the annual cost of conflicted investment advice in the US is $17 billion per year. The scenario outlined in this article is case in point.

The Negative Compounding Effect of Fees

The diminishing effects of the high fees & low service model outlined above are significant. To illustrate, I have provided a compare-and-contrast to what I believe is a more reasonable fee structure of 0.85% in total fees. (This includes an advisor fee of 0.75% and underlying investment fees of 0.10%.) 

After backing out the fees for both scenarios, the difference in future account value after 20 years of saving and investing is $343,000.

If you are an institution, add a zero or two to the end of each number for a better comparison on the effects to your business, organization, non-profit, endowment, foundation, or other.

fees.jpg

Is the “advisor” adding $343k worth of value? That amount would more than cover health care costs for a married couple throughout their retirement years, according to recent studies(3).

 To be clear, advisors can add significant value to a client relationship. Vanguard produced a research piece called the Advisors Alpha®(4) that makes the case that an advisor can add significant value beyond the fee they charge. However, it comes through a combination of wise stewardship and planning, portfolio construction and tax efficiency. In short, it is much work that deserves fair compensation. The challenge with the scenario outlined above is that any advisor would have difficulty justifying their value at that fee level when their only service is setting up an allocation and checking in once a year.

How You Can Avoid This

Having open and honest communication with your advisor is essential. Here are a few questions to ask that can help you determine if your advisor is acting in your best interest and has a compelling service and fee offering:

Fees & Services: What services will I receive and how much will it cost?

  • Service and fee schedules should be clearly outlined so you can determine what you are receiving and how much you are paying. You will be able to measure the potential "Advisors Alpha®." A contract should explicitly outline fees and the commitments being offered such as discretionary investment management, planning services, meetings per year, insurance reviews, risk management, estate planning, reporting and more. If you are an institution this will look slightly different, but it will still be the same idea. If your advisor cannot tell you exactly how they are going to serve you and what their charges will be, it might be best to keep looking.

Investment Fees: What is the fee for the underlying investments held in my account?

  • This question will help you asses the total fee that you will be paying and not just the advisors fee. Typically these investment costs can be minimal for accounts that use individual stocks, bonds, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) and index funds. However, for accounts that use actively managed mutual funds, insurance products or Separately Managed Accounts (SMAs), these fees can add up and take a toll on your long-term return.

Are you a Fiduciary: Are you a legal, written Fiduciary in all matters?

  • If your advisor is not a legal, written Fiduciary in all matters, beware that they have the flexibility to not apply Fiduciary standards in serving you. If they are a Registered Representative, Investment Representative, Broker or Insurance related, there’s a good chance they do not have to act in your best interest.

Are you an Expert: Do you have credentials or an advanced degree in your field of practice?

  • Your advisor should continue to learn and grow throughout their career. Legally, all advisors and brokers must have individual licenses such as the Series 6, Series 65, Series 7, etcetera. This does not make an advisor an expert. It is merely the cost of admission and is the SEC and FINRA's attempt to ensure there is some form of standard in the industry. Look for credentials such as CFA, CFP, CPA, or CIMA and for advanced degrees such as Master’s in Financial Planning or Master of Science in Finance. In short, credentials and advanced degrees help demonstrate the continued efforts of an advisor to learn and stay on top of trends in an incredibly complex and dynamic profession.

If you have questions about this article or any personal or institutional financial needs, we would love to help. Please do not hesitate to reach out to our team.

(1) According to the Chicago Booth Center for Research in Security Prices, from 1/1/1926 to 12/31/2017 the compound annual returns for US stocks were 10.0% and for international stocks, 8.0%. In this article, I have assumed an arbitrary and straightforward 9% average return solely for illustration. This does not constitute investment advice and should not be relied on as such. http://www.crsp.com/resources/investments-illustrated-charts

(2) https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesfinancecouncil/2018/08/17/why-conflicting-retirement-advice-is-crushing-american-households/#4ddfd4f71355 

(3) https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/personal-finance/plan-for-rising-health-care-costs

(4) https://advisors.vanguard.com/VGApp/iip/site/advisor/researchcommentary/article/IWE_ResVgdAdvisorsAlpha

 

Related Articles

Oregon College Savings Plan: Examining the New Changes and Existing Opportunities

Oregon College Savings Plan: Examining the New Changes and Existing Opportunities

Recently, there have been two significant changes that affect the Oregon College Savings Plan (one of the Oregon state-sponsored 529 plans).  This presented an opportunity to share updates and examine commonly overlooked planning opportunities.

Background and Highlights on 529 Plans and Oregon College Savings Plan

  • 529 Plans are State-Sponsored Education Savings Accounts (The Oregon College Savings Plan is one of the available Oregon-sponsored Plans)

  • Tax Advantages of 529 Plans: Taxation Similar to Roth IRA

    • After-Tax Contributions

    • Tax-Free Growth

    • Tax-Free Distributions if used for qualified education expenses

  • If funds are not used for qualified education expenses, the investment growth is subject to ordinary income taxes and a 10% penalty.

  • Oregon provides an incentive for Oregon residents to contribute to an Oregon-sponsored plan:  Oregon state income tax deduction is available for contributions up to $4,750/year (Married filing jointly) and $2,375/year (all other filers) for 2018.  Note: This amount will typically see small increases each year for inflation.

New Plan Manager for The Oregon College Savings Plan

The Oregon College Savings Plan recently decided to change to a new plan manager and the transition is scheduled to be complete by September 12th.  Earlier this year at a local meeting for the Financial Planning Association (FPA) of Oregon & SW Washington, we were able to hear directly from the plan advisor about the anticipated changes, including the details on their thought process and analysis.  After learning more about these changes, they appear to be positive improvements that should help the plan and plan participants.

Highlights of Plan Changes Include:

  • Cost: Currently the fees will be approximately the same as the previous plan, but a new fee structure will allow for the costs to decrease in the future as the plan grows. 

  • Investment Funds: The investment fund lineup has been revamped and now includes additional lower-cost fund options from well established and respected fund companies like Vanguard and DFA.

  • Changes to Age-Based Funds: The previous plan manager had an option to select an age-based portfolio (blend of funds to match the time horizon for college).  The new plan manager improved and optimized this option by doing the following:

    • The old plan used an Age Group (i.e. Age 0-4). The new plan will utilize College Start Date instead since the actual enrollment age can vary. 

    • The old plan assumed an investment time horizon that ended at age 18.  Since college typically extends through age 21-23, the new option expands the investment time for horizon through the end of college.

    • The new plan changes the process for making the portfolio more conservative over time as the beneficiary gets closer to college.  It will now be more gradual and efficient which can mitigate the risk of selling the stock portion of the portfolio on a down market day.

Navigating the New Rule Change for K-12 Expenses

Previously, K-12 private school expenses were not qualified education expenses under a 529 plan.  The recent Tax Cut and Jobs Action of 2017 Tax Act now treats withdrawals for up to $10k/year for K-12 expenses as qualified education expenses.

Oregon did not extend favorable tax treatment for K-12 expenses.  If you take distributions from K-12 expenses, Oregon state income tax deductions previously taken for contributions will be added back to taxable income. In addition, any investment gains will be subject to Oregon state income tax.

The Oregon treatment of this new rule makes it less attractive as a planning strategy for K-12 private school but could still be a viable option to consider under the right circumstances.  If your family cash flow has become tight and private school costs have become stressful for your family, using 529 plan funds could be worth the relief since the tax consequences are now lower.  

For example, you have a non-Oregon 529 Plan where you contributed $8,000 and the account balance has grown to $10,000.  If you withdrew the $10,000 for K-12 private school, you would pay approximately $200 in Oregon taxes ($2,000 gain at 10% = $200).  

What are the Planning Opportunities and Considerations with the Oregon College Savings Plan?

  • Rollover Tax Savings Opportunity: Do you have an existing 529 Plan sponsored by another state?  There is an opportunity to rollover this plan into the Oregon plan and capture immediate savings in Oregon state income taxes even if you don’t make any additional contributions.

  • State Income Tax Deduction Planning: Are you taking full advantage of the Oregon state income tax deduction?  There are other considerations other than contributing the deductible limits each year.  Examples include:  Planning around contributions over the deduction limit that can be carried forward and used in future years (subject to limitations).  Also, it may not be too late if your child is very close to or currently in college.  Contributing funds even if it is for the short-term can still create state income tax savings that you could be missing out on.

  • Be Conscious of Federal Gift Tax Limits: Contributions to a 529 plan are considered gifts and can be subject to gift tax if above $15,000 per donor ($30,000 for married), per beneficiary each year (2018).  Gifts above those thresholds can avoid gift tax but may create added cost and inconvenience of filing a Gift Tax Return.  If you recently received a sum of money like an inheritance, it could make sense to spread the contribution over a few years instead of making one large upfront contribution.

  • Special Needs: If you started a 529 plan and there is a possibility that your child may not be attending college due to special needs, there is an opportunity to roll that account into an ABLE Savings Plan (tax-advantaged savings plan for individuals with disabilities that does not affect their government benefits).  This opportunity is subject to rules and limitations.  For more information click here https://oregonablesavings.com/.

If you want more information or have any questions:

If you have questions or would like more information you can visit www.oregoncollegesavings.com or contact Human Investing through our website at https://www.humaninvesting.com/contact-us/


Marc Kadomatsu
The Dangerous Reality Of Using Your 401k To Finance Your Vacation.
 

Looking to go on a “once and a lifetime” vacation to Fiji? Renovate your kitchen? Upgrade your car? Did you know you may be able to utilize your 401k or other retirement plan to take a loan to help finance this big expense? Here are the details, the dangerous reality, and things to consider when taking a 401k loan:

The Details:

If your plan document permits, a 401k loan can help you access up to $50k of likely your biggest pool of assets, avoid creditors, pay interest back to yourself (typically prime rate + 1%) and there is no need for good credit to qualify. You wouldn’t be the only one taking advantage of this opportunity; according to the National Bureau of Economic Research, about 1 in 5 active participants have a 401k loan.

NBER Working Paper No. 21102

NBER Working Paper No. 21102

The Dangerous Reality:

Does all of this sound too good to be true? Well, it just might be. A 401k loan can come at the cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars in future retirement income (see graph below). So, whether you have a loan or are planning to take a loan, it is important to know some of the dangers of borrowing against your future self:

Forfeit the tax advantage of your retirement plan dollars - When you are paying back your loan, interest payments are done so after tax. This forfeits the tax advantage of these retirement dollars as taxes are paid when you contribute and later withdraw.

Leaving your employer? Think again - If you leave employment at your company, whether by your choice or your employer’s, you will find yourself in a sticky situation. The remaining balance of the loan will need to be paid back by the time you file taxes for the current year. Defaulting on your 401k loan comes at a great cost. The remaining loan balance will be considered taxable income. If you are under age 59 ½, a 10% early withdrawal penalty will be tacked on as well.

Abandon free money – If your 401k has an employer match you may miss out on free money if you cannot afford to continue contributing to your 401k while paying back the loan.

Miss out on market growth - Your dollars are not fully invested while you have an outstanding loan balance. This means a portion of your portfolio would miss out on opportunity for growth, specifically when market returns are greater than the interest rate paid to yourself.

Detrimental impact on retirement income - A 401k loan can have a detrimental impact on your retirement savings and your potential income in retirement. The below graph shows the effects on an individual’s retirement savings and monthly retirement income. Three scenarios shown are 1) take a 401k loan and push pause on contributions; 2) take a 401k loan while continuing to save; and 3) don’t take a loan.

This graph is for illustration purposes only. It highlights the impact a loan has on an individual’s retirement balance and monthly retirement income after 30 years of investment growth during working years (assuming 7% annual market return and annu…

This graph is for illustration purposes only. It highlights the impact a loan has on an individual’s retirement balance and monthly retirement income after 30 years of investment growth during working years (assuming 7% annual market return and annual contributions of $7,500) and 30 years of income through retirement (assuming 4% rate of return). In this example an individual takes a $15k 401(k) loan from a $50k balance to pay down some bills and a finance a vacation.

The “once in a lifetime trip to Fiji” can ultimately cost more than $1,400 per month in retirement income.

That’s $515k over 30 years of retirement!

Options to consider:

For some, a 401k loan can be a helpful tool when “life happens,” allowing participants of retirement plans the ability to access a pool of assets intended for retirement. However, while this can be an attractive tool for some, borrowing from your future self can have its drawbacks. Either way, here are issues worth thinking about:

  • Want to go on a once in a life time trip to Fiji, or finance some other big expense that isn’t worth putting your retirement income in risk? Budget for future big expenses, plan and start saving today.

  • Building an emergency reserve (3-6month’s income) to keep you on track financially and avoid a last resort 401k loan when an unexpected expense comes up.

  • Are you in a pinch and need to take a loan or have already taken a loan? Continue saving in to your retirement account so as to not miss out on valuable retirement savings and possible employer match.

  • Want to take a 401k loan? Check with your HR representative or 401k advisor to see what options are available to you.

 

 
 

Related Articles

Closing The Gap For The Retirement Haves And Have-Nots
 

This article was originally published on Forbes.

Shutterstock

Shutterstock

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) was established in 1974 to give employees retirement income security. Why, then, after 40-plus years, are Americans so underprepared for retirement?

According to a 2015 study from the Government Accountability Office, "About half of households age 55 and older have no retirement savings (such as in a 401(k) plan or an IRA)." Even those who have saved have saved poorly. Among those households of residents ages 55 to 64 with some retirement savings, the median amount saved is $104,000. For those 65 to 74, the amount is roughly $148,000 per household. And, with 70% of the civilian population having access to a retirement plan and 91% access for government employees, it’s a wonder there is such a lack of retirement readiness.

There is no shortage of financial and intellectual capital being spent on a solution for retirement readiness. But most solutions have fallen short of narrowing the gap between the retirement haves and have-nots. So, what is the solution? My thoughts follow:

Government Plus Employer Plus Employee

First, the government is already involved in the regulation of retirement plans, as well as allowing for employers to deduct the expenses of having a plan, so why not go all in? Why not tell employers, “If you are going to get the deduction, you need to meet certain requirements that are great for employees, great for your business and great for our country”?

Those requirements could include auto-enrollment (as this has been a home-run for participation), auto-increase (as individuals get raises, they add a little more to their retirement) and an eligible age-based default option (eligibility for a great default option would be low-cost and diversified as you get from the likes of popular mutual fund providers with their index retirement glide path funds).

In order to qualify for a business deduction or incentive from the government, an employer would be required to match a certain amount. I’d propose 5%, with the employee required to commit 5% to get that amount. Why these amounts? Because if someone has a job for 40 years and invests in a basket of mutual funds growing at or around 8%, with both the employee and employer contributing at 5% each, they end up a millionaire (assuming a $36,000 annual salary, or $300 per month contributions, compounded monthly for 40 years.)

The Industry

In a recent Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) study, more than 70% of HR professionals surveyed emphasized the importance a retirement savings plan. So, at a minimum, employees are aware of the need to save and desire to do so. While there is definitely a need amongst employees to save for retirement, there are several barriers that impact participants interest and willingness to save. First, trust among advisors is low. Second, many plans have a dizzying array of options, which negatively impacts deferral rates. Finally, not all employers offer to match contributions, which minimizes the incentive for employees to contribute to the 401(k) versus less automated choices, like an IRA.

So, what can the industry do to partner with employers and their workforce? There are two things in my view:

1. Understand the heart of ERISA. Advisors and their firms are to put the interests of the employee and their income security at the center of everything they are doing. If, somehow, the advice we are giving in any way conflicts with the employee and their security, then we should reassess what we are doing and meet the stated purpose of ERISA -- it doesn’t need to be any more complex.

2. In order to minimize the potential for anything but the fiduciary standard, any firm operating in the retirement space should be required to be a fiduciary and have no ability to be dually registered or receive commissions, kickbacks, trips or any other super-secret benefit.

Join the small percentage of firms that are truly fee-only and have no way of receiving any form of compensation other than from the client. Disclosing away conflicts is not the answer for the clients, as few read the disclosures they are provided. If we are going to serve clients well, eliminating the ability for the conflict to exist is the only reasonable route to go.

In conclusion, the government is already involved in both rule-making and incentives for companies and their employees to offer and invest in retirement plans. A model for offering a retirement plan that meets certain criteria in order to fully receive the incentive should be outlined and adhered to by companies and their employees. In partnership with the government, employers and employees, the financial services community should be held to a higher standard to eliminate the conflicts that keep retirement plans for becoming all they could be, which is for employee retirement income security.

 

 
 

Related Articles

Introducing 450 Publishing. Sign up today
 

What is 450 you ask?

It is a name that finds it’s inspiration in the lives of savers and investors. In essence the name is “for the fifty.” But each of us must ask ourselves “which fifty am I?” or “which fifty do I want to be?”

Are you at risk of becoming...

 
 
fifty percent v1.jpg
 
 
fifty percent v2.jpg
 
 

You see, 450 is most of us. 

We’re either hoping Social Security will help us out or hoping our modest savings will miraculously stretch across 20-30 years of retirement.

The good news is it’s never too late to start.

There is always hope and opportunity to put a little away now so that you can live the life you want to live when work is no longer an option and retirement is upon you. Our publishing company, which is focused on and created “for the fifty” will deliver topics that are easy to read and always written with you in mind. Our goal is to educate and equip savers every step of the way.

 
Human Investing
Stop winging it. Why you should start your financial plan now
 

As our friends at Charles Schwab post their 2018 Modern Wealth Index data[1], their research findings are eye-opening:   

  1. Sixty percent of Americans live paycheck to paycheck

  2. Only twenty-five percent have a written financial plan.

Ultimately, the Schwab findings point to a challenging financial future for most American.  About one-half of all American households with residents age 55 and older have no savings such as a 401(k) plan or IRA.  The latest GAO report findings make sense given the number of workers living paycheck to paycheck.

pete-blog.jpg

Money isn’t something a whole lot of people enjoy talking about, but at some point, the tone should change so that we can put these glaring facts on the table and work towards a flexible solution.  It seems the findings are explicit (at least with the 2018 Modern Wealth Index): if you have a written plan, you’ll be in the top decile of financial performers.  In other words, you’ll put yourself in an optimal position to have both financial peace and wellness.

[1] www.aboutschwab.come/modern-wealth-index-2018

 

 
 

Related Articles

What You Need to Know About Sequence Risk
 

Image credit: Amol Tyagi

Over the last nine months since my daughter was born, I have learned to hear and translate her grunts, squeals, cries, and even noises that sound very similar to what a pterodactyl probably sounded like. The other night I woke to a cry that was not familiar. In her sleep she had stuck her foot through the slats in the side of the crib, but when she turned to pull her foot out, she could not; her foot was stuck. Putting her foot in the space between slats was easy, pulling it out…well, that was a different story.

This experience can be similar to that of an investor who has saved well for retirement but may have difficulties withdrawing dollars due to Sequence Risk. Sequence Risk, also known as sequence of return risk, is the risk assumed by an investor taking withdrawals from an investment account when receiving lower or negative investment returns. Specifically, this becomes serious early on in someone’s withdrawal timeline, as the investor/retiree ends up withdrawing a larger portion of their total portfolio than planned. Knowing what Sequence Risk is and how to plan for it is instrumental to a successful long-term financial plan. To illustrate Sequence Risk and its impact, let’s first look at the 20-year experience of two investors who are not taking withdrawals (Scenario 1) compared to the experience of the same two investors who are withdrawing from their accounts during that same 20-year period (Scenario 2).

A Scenario of Two Markets

Investor A deposits a lump sum of $400,000 in the S&P 500 (500 biggest companies in the US) on January 1, 1998. Investor A does not touch her investments for 20 years and now her balance is over $1,600,000, despite both the Dotcom Crash and the 2008 Financial Crisis. A great reward for the disciplined long-term investor.

With Investor B we see a similar scenario. She deposits a lump sum of $400,000 in the S&P 500 and doesn’t touch it for 20 years. Except this time the annual returns of the S&P 500, while staying the same, are randomized in their order and weighted for an early market downturn of two consecutive years of negative returns (-37% and -22.1%). After 20 years Investor B arrives at the same balance of over $1,600,000.

Scenario 1:

chart1.jpg

For the long-term investor, the sequence of returns does not seem to influence the investor’s portfolio if he or she is not withdrawing from their investments. Both Investor A and Investor B, while having very different market experiences, arrive at the same place. A great case for the long-term investor to not balk at market volatility.

The Sequence Risk for a Retiree

Where the order of returns does impact the investor (i.e., a retiree) is when they begin withdrawing from their investments in a down market. To see the impact Sequence Risk has on an investor, we will look at the same investment returns experienced by Investor A and Investor B. In this scenario the difference is each investor will begin taking annual withdrawals of $20,000 (5% of beginning balance) at the end of each year.

With Investor A, we see after the market experience of the S&P 500 from 1998 to 2017, she would expect to have $618k after 20 years of retirement.

As for Investor B, when the market experience begins with a downturn for the investor, the retiree’s balance would be significantly less, only $193k. A difference in the order of returns can mean a difference of almost $425k, or a 1/3 of the portfolio size, after 20 years.

Scenario 2:

chart2.jpg

Why does it matter?

Two retirees with identical wealth can have entirely different financial outcomes, depending on the state of the market when they start retirement and begin taking withdrawals, even if the long-term market averages are the same.

What do you need to do?

While you cannot control what the sequence of future returns is, there are things you can do to impact the success of your financial plan. If you are a long-term investor, make sure you have a plan, revisit the plan annually, and stay disciplined. If you are already in or are entering retirement, it is important for you and your advisor to plan accordingly:

Assess your risk. Appropriately assess your risk as you are entering retirement years. Assuming more risk than necessary paired with a down market can make you greatly susceptible to Sequence Risk.

Lower retirement expenses. Pay off any debt (including mortgage payments) before entering into retirement. Having fewer expenses in retirement provides flexibility for when the markets get rocky and withdrawing less is prudent (based on what was just laid out about Sequence Risk).

Have a short-term strategy be a part of your long-term financial plan. Hold assets that allow for flexible spending without having to veer from your long-term strategy. Holding cash or fixed income investments can provide short-term income sources, helping you avoid withdrawing a large portion of your total portfolio in a down market.

Continue working. If entering into a market experiencing low or negative returns, keep your job. What no retiree wants to hear after a long career of hard work! However, continuing to save and to delay retirement withdrawals by even a few years has the potential to yield long-term exponential growth.

While my daughter had no issue putting her foot in the space between slats, the issue was pulling her foot out. Dad was able to save the day. Realizing the most efficient angle, I was able to help her pull her foot out. With investors, sometimes it takes someone to come alongside and help strategize the most efficient strategy to withdraw dollars, no matter what is going on in the market. If you are planning on retiring soon and want help building a tailored financial plan and assessing the risk on your retirement accounts, let us know. Human Investing is here to help.   

*Scenarios are used for illustration purposes only. Past performance is not an indicator of future outcomes.

 

 
 

Related Articles

Why Dollar-Cost Averaging is a Great Investment Strategy
 

A recent theme in our client conversations has been around the timing of investing. On a regular basis we hear the question, “when is the right time to invest?” especially when times are uncertain. It’s a great question, one that is worth considering, but before answering this question let me state: We at Human Investing are long-term investors. Don’t mistake that for “buy and hold,” but rather “buy and assess.” Additionally, we believe financial planning is the key to investment success. While planning does not guarantee success, it does improve the odds of a successful outcome. In our advisory practice, the financial plan informs the investment decision.

Once the plan is in place and we’ve made the decision to invest, the timing of investing may not always mean we push a button to invest one hundred percent of someone’s capital in that moment. What it does mean is that we have a thoughtful discussion on the different strategies we might utilize to put the money to work, choosing the right option based on the client’s plan and their input.

Let’s walk through an example. The chart below is a hypothetical client who invests $500 per month ($6k/year) over an eleven year period starting January 2007 and ending December 2017. For this exercise we simulated investing the $500/month into a simple total stock market index exchange-traded fund with the symbol ITOT. The total invested capital in 2007 was $66,000 with net proceeds of $136,809 on the last day of 2017. Pretty incredible results considering the eleven year time frame included small gain and loss years of 2007, 2011, and 2015 and a large loss of 39.42% in 2008.

Picture1.png

This is a great example of a strategy called dollar-cost averaging. Dollar-cost averaging is an investment strategy with the goal of reducing the impact of volatility on large purchases by adding small amounts of the intended purchase into the market over a specified period of time. Technically speaking, taking a lump sum and immediately investing the funds for an extended period of time is the best option. The challenge with the lump sum method is that many investors struggle to invest 100% of their money right away due to factors like willpower and emotion. With the dollar-cost averaging approach the investor puts his money to work bit-by-bit, which for many, feels good emotionally and prevents money ear-marked for investing from staying in cash too long. For these reasons and others, the methodical dollar-cost averaging approach has become the most successful way to invest capital for the long-run.

My intent is not to vilify a cash investment as bad. For many investors cash has a place and a purpose within their overall portfolio. I’m looking to highlight an effective approach/strategy for when a client’s financial plan requires a greater return than 1%.  

If you’ve asked the question, “What is this money for?” and the timeline is long-term, consider the total sum you are looking to invest, divide that sum into a reasonable time period and make a commitment to dollar-cost average those funds into the market. In doing so you won’t find that you’ve kept the funds in cash for any longer than is necessary, and you will be well on your way to your stated long-term savings and investment goal.

 

 
 

Related Articles